Research · value ratings

Value ratings

Is a share cheap, fair or expensive at today's metal prices? 14 companies, rated on 16 Nov 2026 from the close of Fri 13 Nov (Hecla Mining: rated on 17 Nov 2026 from the close of Mon 16 Nov; Aya Gold & Silver: price-based on a later close). Today: 7 expensive, 7 fair, 0 cheap.

Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.

How a rating works

A rating weighs two futures, the plan working or not, by their chances, and compares the expected value of a share at the end of the horizon (usually four years) with today's price. Expensive is 1.1× or less (about 2.4% a year or less) plus a written reason. Cheap is 2.0× or more (about 19% a year) plus a written reason, a dated catalyst and no tripped thesis breaker. Everything between is fair.

Every page has sliders to try your own assumptions and the full calculation, starting with the calculation in brief. How we rate a share, with two worked examples →

Gold & silver developers

Fair2.05×NexGold MiningTSXV: NEXG · last close C$1.120 (€0.711) · worth in Nov 2030 C$2.302 (€1.461) · confidence lowFair1.56×Emperor MetalsCSE: AUOZ · last close C$0.400 (€0.254) · worth in Nov 2030 C$0.626 (€0.397) · confidence lowFair1.27×Vizsla SilverNYSE American: VZLA · last close US$3.07 (€2.78) · worth in Dec 2029 US$3.88 (€3.51) · confidence lowExpensive0.77×Argenta SilverTSXV: AGAG · last close C$0.290 (€0.184) · worth in Nov 2030 C$0.224 (€0.142) · confidence medium on the rating, low on the values

Gold & silver producers

Fair1.29×Avino Silver & Gold MinesNYSE American / TSX: ASM · last close US$4.29 (€3.88) · worth in Nov 2030 US$5.52 (€4.99) · confidence lowFair1.16×Aya Gold & SilverTSX / Nasdaq: AYA · last close C$30.38 (€19.31) · worth in Nov 2030 C$35.33 (€22.45) · confidence lowFair1.08×Hecla Mining numbers say expensiveNYSE: HL · last close US$12.22 (€11.09) · worth in Nov 2030 US$13.19 (€11.98) · confidence low

Copper

Fair1.38×Western Copper and GoldTSX: WRN · last close C$2.04 (€1.29) · worth in Nov 2030 C$2.81 (€1.78) · confidence lowExpensive1.02×Aldebaran ResourcesTSXV: ALDE · last close C$2.74 (€1.74) · worth in Nov 2030 C$2.81 (€1.78) · confidence lowExpensive0.81×Hot ChiliASX / TSXV: HCH · last close A$1.305 (€0.801) · worth in Nov 2030 A$1.052 (€0.646) · confidence mediumExpensive0.70×Copper Giant ResourcesTSXV: CGNT · last close C$0.850 (€0.539) · worth in Nov 2030 C$0.596 (€0.379) · confidence medium

Critical minerals

Expensive0.83×Centaurus MetalsASX: CTM · last close A$0.360 (€0.221) · worth in Dec 2030 A$0.298 (€0.183) · confidence lowExpensive0.71×NexGen EnergyTSX / NYSE: NXE · last close C$11.05 (€7.01) · worth in Sep 2030 C$7.83 (€4.97) · confidence mediumExpensive0.61×Ucore Rare MetalsTSXV: UCU · last close C$2.18 (€1.38) · worth in Nov 2030 C$1.34 (€0.85) · confidence low

Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.

Chung Huynh is an independent equity researcher, not a licensed financial adviser.

The author may own shares in companies rated here and may buy or sell them at any time.

A rating is reviewed when the price crosses one of its two levels, after major news or a dated catalyst, and at least every three months.

Ratings use today's metal prices. Every number shows its date and source; figures marked estimate are the desk's own.

Educational research, not personal financial advice.