ASX / TSXV: HCH · Copper
A copper developer in Chile (Costa Fuego, Atacama region): pre-feasibility study done, looking for a partner and the money to build.
Expensive · dilution: even success pays about 1.2×
Changed on 16 Nov: the chance it works is now the analyst's own figure from the deep dive, 30% (before, 36%, the figure the rankings page used). Before: 0.84×, expensive. Now: 0.81×, expensive. Re-run by the analyst and checked by an independent re-run.
Confidence: medium. Medium in the label, low in the figure. The label holds in every case tried: 0.30× to 0.88× across the low and high cases, and 0.90× at US$8/lb copper. The figure is weak: the partner price, debt share, overrun reserve and spending are estimates; the study value is stretched beyond its tested range; gold is held at the study price; La Verde and Huasco Water are not in the model.
What one share should be worth in Nov 2030, by the analyst's estimate:
Works means La Verde holds and a partner or a water sale funds the Costa Fuego build by 31 Dec 2028; valued on 13 Nov 2030 as a funded build.
Fails means No partner or water deal funds the build by 31 Dec 2028; on 13 Nov 2030 the project is stuck at pre-feasibility stage, valued at no more than today's value per pound, and the company has sold shares at a distressed price to keep going.
Per share, after the new shares each path needs, so each value compares directly with today's price. € at the ECB reference rate of 13 Nov 2026 (1.6288 A$ per €); the rating itself is worked out in Australian dollars, and future exchange rates will differ.
Expensive at 1.10× or less, cheap at 2.00× or more. Expensive also needs a written reason; cheap also needs a written reason, a dated catalyst and no tripped thesis breaker.
Latest close, Mon 16 Nov 2026: A$1.250 (€0.767), in the expensive range. Same range as the rating.
The new shares and options each path needs are re-priced at each level.
No cheap price. Price alone won't make this share cheap; it would take good news (see “What would change the rating”).
A share counts as cheap here if, on average, it should be worth at least 2.00 times its price by Nov 2030. Worked out on paper, that would happen at A$0.375 a share. But at that price a share would still be worth A$0.816 if the project stalls, because that value is fixed at today's prices (what the market pays today for this company or for similar stalled projects) and does not fall with the share price. The sum would then say you make money even if everything goes wrong, which is not believable: if the share really fell that far, the value if it stalls would fall with it. So the page shows no cheap price instead of a misleading number.
At the rankings' own target: 1.03×. At the rankings page's own target of 0.40 times study value, a funded build is worth 1.98 times today's price and the expected value is 1.03×: under the 1.1× line, so this yardstick also reads expensive. Shown beside the rating, never counted.
At the top metal price on the rankings: If copper were US$8/lb, the top regular price on the rankings page (not a forecast): value if it works 1.55×, expected value 0.90×, still expensive. Shown beside the rating, never counted.
If Hot Chili sold its water business: If Hot Chili sold its 80% stake in Huasco Water for the first stage's study value (US$97.6M, the study's base case) and the mine were then funded, a share would be worth 1.56 times the 13 Nov close instead of 1.23 and the expected value would rise from 0.81× to 0.90×, still under the 1.1× line for expensive (reaching it would take about US$206M for the stake). Shown beside the rating, never counted: there is no deal and no market price for Huasco Water. Try it with the “Cash for its 80% of Huasco Water” slider.
The value at metal futures prices about three years out is pending for all 14 (exchange data on hold).
Expensive. At A$1.305 (close of Fri 13 Nov 2026) the expected value of a share in four years is 0.81 times today's price, under the 1.1× line for expensive. The expected value weighs a share's value if the plan works and if it fails by their chances. Even with a partner and 55% debt (estimates), Hot Chili must sell about A$467M of new shares, 1.8 times the market value of its shares in issue, so the share count rises about 3.2-fold. A funded Costa Fuego is then worth 1.23 times today's price, at what the market pays for copper projects with a feasibility study (0.17 of their study value, the after-tax net present value in their studies, on enterprise value: shares plus debt minus cash), with Hot Chili's share of the build equity added. A stalled one is worth 0.62 times (today's value per pound of copper, after a rescue share issue). The analyst's chance of a funded build by 31 Dec 2028 (a judgement): 30%.
Price alone won't make this cheap. What could raise the value: the La Verde maiden resource (no company date; expected by 31 Dec 2026 on the research team's reading, and a thesis breaker (a dated test, set in advance, that would show the case is wrong) trips if it is below 350 million tonnes or not out by 31 Mar 2027), a revised pre-feasibility study including La Verde (2027), the environmental submissions for the water intake and the mine (Q2 2027), and a partner (a process run by the bank BMO) or a Huasco Water deal, which the plan needs by 31 Dec 2028. A partner who paid Hot Chili's whole share of the build equity would lift the expected value to about 1.26×, fair.
Already expensive. It would turn fair only below about A$0.835 with nothing else changed. It gets worse with no binding partner or water deal by 31 Dec 2028, a La Verde resource below 350 million tonnes, or a share issue below A$1.00.
Set in advance: any one of these would mean the plan has failed or the rating must be redone.
| When | What |
|---|---|
| by late Dec 2026 | Last La Verde assays (21 holes); the maiden La Verde resource follows once they are in, with no date, so not before 2027 (Hot Chili's ASX release of 17 Nov 2026 AEDT as news reports give it; the release itself not yet read) |
| 25 Nov 2026 | Annual general meeting (vote on room to place 10% more shares) |
| by 31 Dec 2026 (desk reading; the company gives no date) | La Verde first resource |
| about 29 Jan 2027 | December quarterly report and cash |
| Q2 2027 | Environmental filings for the water intake and the mine |
| 31 Dec 2028 | Cut-off for a partner or water deal |
Move a slider, and the value, the rating and the two price levels are worked out again with the same arithmetic as the rating above. The gold mark on each scale is the desk's setting; tap a chip to jump to a value.
The sliders run the analyst's own rating function (translated line by line from Python and tested against it on random inputs), so at the desk's settings they give exactly the card's numbers, and the two price levels are worked out again at each setting. The label here follows the numbers; cheap also needs the cheap line without late builds, and the written tests. Metal prices and costs are held flat to the end of the horizon.
The same function at the rankings page's regular price columns: sensitivities, not forecasts. Costa Fuego's NPV on its copper line (US$95M per 10 cents beyond US$5.30); gold at the study deck; the multiple, the partner terms, the raise and the fail value held. Peer multiples, the stalled value and the cap on the value if it fails are held at the start close; in reality they move with the metal. Columns far above a study's tested range are rough; costs are held flat. Sensitivities, not forecasts.
Swipe the table sideways for more columns →
| Price | Expected value | If it works | If it fails | Cheap below | Expensive above |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| copper US$5/lb | 0.75× · expensive | 1.03× | 0.62× | none | A$0.765 |
| copper US$6/lb | 0.80× · expensive | 1.20× | 0.62× | none | A$0.824 |
| copper US$7/lb | 0.85× · expensive | 1.37× | 0.62× | none | A$0.889 |
| copper US$8/lb | 0.90× · expensive | 1.55× | 0.62× | none | A$0.961 |
Hot Chili is worth about A$1.604 a share in Nov 2030 if the plan works and A$0.815 if it fails. At a 30% chance the expected value is A$1.052, 0.81× today's A$1.305: expensive.
Each step says first what its numbers are, then what the step does, then shows the sum.
Shares times price is what the whole company costs on the stock market today. Everything below is compared with this price.
A study is a plan, not a result, so the market pays less than the full study value.
The equity that goes into the mine is added once.
Even with a partner and 55% debt, Hot Chili must sell many new shares: the count rises about 3.2-fold.
All of the company's value divided by all the shares there will be (208.05 + 447.18 = 655.23M), then compared with today's price.
If no partner or water deal funds the build by end-2028, the project is worth what the market pays for Hot Chili today, no more. No late-build case: the works state is a funded build.
Each future counts by its chance. Over 4.00 years, 1.10× or less is expensive and 2.00× or more is cheap; between is fair. Expensive and cheap also need the written tests.
The share prices at which, everything else as above, the rating would turn.
Where a reasonable person could choose differently, and what that would do. Each result is the model re-run with that one change; the sliders above let you combine them.
The analyst's lines below are for the earlier case (chance 36%, expected value 0.842×). The calculation in brief above uses the case of 16 Nov.
Codes in the analyst's own notes: E = expected value as a multiple of today's price; Mw, Mf = value if it works, if it fails; pw = chance it works; q = share of misses that are late builds; hurdle = 1.5 times in four years (10.7% a year); A1 = valued at what the market pays similar companies today; C4 = new shares for the money still to raise; F1 = the value if it fails is capped at the company's own value today per unit; F2 = a rescue share sale at 80% of value; F3 = a late build valued like success, discounted for the delay; R1 = the written-reason test; X1 = currencies converted at the ECB rate of the start date; yardstick B = the rankings' own target, shown and never counted.
Costa Fuego NPV at today's copper: 2,180 + 8.73 × 95 = US$3,009.4M (100%). A1 on EV: copper FS / permitted EV ÷ NPV, whole group: Western 0.030 (X1), Highland 0.048, Marimaca 0.289, Ivanhoe 0.311 → median 0.1684 × 3,009.4 × 62.8% = US$318.3M + Hot Chili's share of the build equity 62.8% × 628.65 = US$394.7M = US$713.0M = A$1,050.8M ÷ 655.23M shares (447.2M new at A$1.044 for A$466.9M) = A$1.60. Fail at the F1 cap: own EV US$159.8M = A$235.5M; shortfall A$55.8M; F2 price A$0.691 → 80.8M new shares → A$0.82.
| Metal column | E | Works | Fail | Cheap below | Expensive above |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| copper US$5/lb | 0.77× | 1.03× | 0.62× | no cheap level | A$0.77 |
| copper US$6/lb | 0.83× | 1.20× | 0.62× | no cheap level | A$0.85 |
| copper US$7/lb | 0.89× | 1.37× | 0.62× | no cheap level | A$0.94 |
| copper US$8/lb | 0.96× | 1.55× | 0.62× | no cheap level | A$1.03 |
Method: Costa Fuego's NPV on its copper line (US$95M per 10 cents beyond US$5.30); gold at the study deck; the multiple, the partner terms, the raise and the fail value held. Limits: Peer multiples, the stalled value and the F1 cap are held at the start close; in reality they move with the metal. Columns far above a study's tested range are rough; costs are held flat. Sensitivities, not forecasts.
# Hot Chili (ASX/TSXV: HCH) - value rating v0.4.1 (16 Nov 2026). US$M unless marked; share values A$.
# Rule set v0.4.1: A1 on EV / study NPV (own raise credited separately): copper 'FS / permitted, unfunded', whole
# group (fewer than five names), Western on its X1 study value; Hot Chili's share of the equity put into the
# project added once. F1: the stalled project at the cap (Hot Chili's own EV per lb today, 2.28 c/lb on 7,007 Mlb
# = its EV of US$159.8M), F2 raise; q = 0 (works state is a funded build, not production).
AUD = 1.1052 / 1.6288 # US$ per A$, ECB 13 Nov 2026
CAD_FX = 1.5758 / 1.1052 # C$ per US$
DEFAULTS = dict(
P=1.305, # share price, A$ (start close 13 Nov 2026)
pw=0.36,
cu=6.173,
ev_nav=[240.0 / (11565.2 / CAD_FX), 44.2 / 915.2, 901.1 / 2895.1, 486.4 / 1685.5], # Western, Highland, Ivanhoe, Marimaca
stake=0.897 * 0.70, # Hot Chili's share after a partner takes 30% of its 89.7%
capex=1270.0, overrun=0.10, debt_share=0.55, partner=220.0, pre_build=80.0,
stalled=159.8, # US$M, the cap: 2.28 c/lb x 7,007 Mlb (= Hot Chili's EV at the start close)
cash_A=29.2, spend_fail_A=85.0,
years=4.0,
)
SHARES = 202.901656 + 5.149759 # shares + rights with no exercise price
def npv_today(cu):
"""Costa Fuego PFS after-tax NPV8, US$M, 100%: 1,200 @ 4.30, 1,610 @ 4.70, 2,180 @ 5.30; last step US$95M per 10c."""
if cu >= 4.70: return 1610 + (cu - 4.70) * 950
return 1200 + (cu - 4.30) * 1025
def _m(i):
s = sorted(i['ev_nav']); n = len(s)
return i.get('m', s[n // 2] if n % 2 else (s[n // 2 - 1] + s[n // 2]) / 2)
def _branches(i, P):
eq_total = i['capex'] * (1 + i['overrun']) * (1 - i['debt_share'])
hch_eq = i['stake'] * eq_total # equity put into the project (HCH share)
raise_us = i['stake'] * (eq_total - i['partner']) + i['pre_build'] - i['cash_A'] * AUD
new = raise_us / AUD / (0.8 * P)
Vw = _m(i) * npv_today(i['cu']) * i['stake'] + hch_eq
Mw_ps = Vw / AUD / (SHARES + new)
A = i['stalled'] / AUD; s = i['spend_fail_A'] - i['cash_A']
if A - s <= 0: Ms_ps = 0.0
else:
p = 0.8 * (A - s) / SHARES; Ms_ps = A / (SHARES + s / p)
return dict(m=_m(i), npv=npv_today(i['cu']), raise_A=raise_us / AUD, new_shares=new, shares_works=SHARES + new,
Mw_ps=Mw_ps, M_stalled_ps=Ms_ps, Mf_ps=Ms_ps)
def value(inp=None):
i = dict(DEFAULTS, **(inp or {})); P = i['P']; b = _branches(i, P)
E = (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['Mf_ps']) / P
return dict(b, Mw=b['Mw_ps'] / P, Mf=b['Mf_ps'] / P, E=E, per_year=E ** (1 / i['years']) - 1)
def _E(i, P):
b = _branches(i, P); return (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['Mf_ps']) / P, b
def _cross(i, line, hi, lo=0.01, steps=4000):
import math
prev = hi
for k in range(steps + 1):
P = hi * math.exp(math.log(lo / hi) * k / steps)
if _E(i, P)[0] >= line:
a, b = P, prev
for _ in range(60):
mid = (a + b) / 2
a, b = (mid, b) if _E(i, mid)[0] >= line else (a, mid)
return a
prev = P
return None
def levels(inp=None):
i = dict(DEFAULTS, **(inp or {})); y = i['years']; hi = 10 * i['P']
exp = _cross(i, 1.1 ** (y / 4), hi); cheap = _cross(i, 2.0 ** (y / 4), hi)
fps = _E(i, cheap)[1]['M_stalled_ps'] if cheap else None
return dict(expensive_above=exp, cheap_below=(cheap if cheap and cheap > fps else None),
cheap_arith=cheap, fail_ps_at_cheap=fps)
if __name__ == '__main__':
r = value(); l = levels()
print({k: round(v, 4) for k, v in r.items()}); print(l)
# desk, 16 Nov: the counted case
DEFAULTS.update({'pw': 0.3})Fact from a filing, exchange or agency · Estimate the desk's own · Desk choice a judgement you can challenge.
Every number here is computed by the same model that drives the rating card and the sliders, so the three cannot disagree.
How we rate a share, with two worked examples →
Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.
Chung Huynh is an independent equity researcher, not a licensed financial adviser.
The author may own shares in companies rated here and may buy or sell them at any time.
A rating is reviewed when the price crosses one of its two levels, after major news or a dated catalyst, and at least every three months.
Ratings use today's metal prices. Every number shows its date and source; figures marked estimate are the desk's own.
Educational research, not personal financial advice.