Cheap, fair or expensive: what each label means, how it is worked out, and two worked examples with their numbers.
In one line: we estimate what a share is likely to be worth in about four years, weigh the good and the bad outcome by their chances, and compare that with today's price.
A rating is not a buy or sell recommendation and not a price target. It answers one question: at today's price, are you paid enough for the risks you take? Educational research, not personal financial advice.
In the examples: fact a number from a filing, a price series or a company release; estimate a number the analyst worked out, with its assumption; judgement a choice the analyst made, with its reason.
Then: expected value = chance it works × value if it works + chance it fails × value if it fails, as a multiple of today's price.
| Expected value in 4 years | Label | Also needed |
|---|---|---|
| 2.0 times today's price or more (about 19% a year) | cheap | 2.0 times also when no late builds are counted, a written reason the market is wrong, a dated event that should close the gap, no thesis breaker tripped, and a second review |
| more than 1.1 times, less than 2.0 times | fair | – |
| 1.1 times or less (about 2.4% a year or less) | expensive | a written reason the market's hopes are unlikely to hold |
A company whose plan has its own date three to five years away is judged over that time, at the same yearly rates. A late build is a plan that still happens, but after its date; it counts as part of “fails”, valued like success but later, and it is left out for the cheap test.
Copper Giant owns Mocoa, a large copper deposit in Colombia. It has no economic study yet.
Today. fact Close on Fri 13 Nov 2026: C$0.85. Shares: 262.5 million. Market value: C$223 million. No debt. The resource: 11,490 million pounds of copper, 81% of it in the least certain category (“Inferred”). Cash: about C$45 million estimate: the 30 Jun statements plus the August placement, less one quarter of spending.
Step 1 · What has to go right. By 2030 the licence dispute ends well and a pre-feasibility study (the second of three study stages) confirms the economics, with a miner as partner or buyer.
Step 2 · The chance. 18% judgement, the analyst's figure from the deep dive.
Step 3 · Value if it works. Companies whose copper projects have a pre-feasibility study trade at a median of 2.29 US cents per pound of copper in the ground fact: three companies, from 0.83 to 3.76 cents, the desk's table of 13 Nov 2026. Mocoa at 2.29 cents is worth US$263 million, or C$375 million. Getting there costs about C$104 million estimate: about C$25 million a year for four years. The company has about C$80 million on hand once its warrants and options are used fact: 81.8 million warrants and 8.7 million options priced below C$0.85. The C$24 million still missing is raised at C$0.68 (today's price less 20%): 35 million new shares. Shares then: 388 million, 48% more than today. Value per share: C$375 million ÷ 388 million = C$0.97, or 1.14 times today's price.
Step 4 · Value if it fails. Copper projects stuck at the first-study stage trade at a median of 1.31 cents a pound fact: five companies. That is more than the market pays for Mocoa today, 1.09 cents. A stalled project cannot be worth more than the same project with its chances intact, so we use 1.09 cents: C$178 million judgement, the rule. Four years of spending that builds nothing (about C$74 million estimate) leave a gap of about C$4 million, raised at a rescue price. Value per share: C$0.52, or 0.61 times today's price.
Step 5 · The weighted result. 0.18 × 1.14 + 0.82 × 0.61 = 0.70 times today's price. A share bought at C$0.85 would be expected to be worth about C$0.60 in four years, about -8% a year. That is below 1.1 times.
Why the market might be wrong. judgement Even if everything goes right, a share is worth about 1.14 times today's price. Reaching a pre-feasibility study roughly doubles what the market pays per pound (from 1.09 to 2.29 cents), but the C$104 million it costs and a share count that grows by about half take most of that gain. For today's price to be even fair, a successful Mocoa would have to be valued at about 6.7 cents a pound, more than any of its three closest peers. Label: expensive.
What would change it. At C$0.53 or less, with nothing else changed, the label would be fair: the same values, with more shares sold at the lower price. A first study showing a much larger value than the market expects would also change it; it is due by 30 Nov 2026.
What the rankings page would say instead. Shown, not counted. The rankings use a more generous target: about 2.3 – 6.3 times today's price if the plan works (midpoint 4.3). On that target the expected value would be 1.27 times, fair. We count the first way because it rests on prices investors actually pay today.
Copper Giant's full deep dive, with sliders and every step →
Hot Chili has a pre-feasibility study for Costa Fuego in Chile: after tax and discounted at 8% a year, worth US$1.2 billion at US$4.30 copper and about US$3.0 billion at today's US$6.17 fact, the study's own price table, extended at its last step (an estimate beyond its tested range). The build costs US$1.27 billion; the company has A$29 million of cash fact.
The numbers in the two examples are worked out from the same rating functions as the company pages, at the close of Fri 13 Nov 2026.
Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.
Chung Huynh is an independent equity researcher, not a licensed financial adviser.
The author may own shares in companies rated here and may buy or sell them at any time.
A rating is reviewed when the price crosses one of its two levels, after major news or a dated catalyst, and at least every three months.
Ratings use today's metal prices. Every number shows its date and source; figures marked estimate are the desk's own.
Educational research, not personal financial advice.