All value ratingsGold & silver producers

Hecla Mining

NYSE: HL · Gold & silver producers

A US silver producer (Greens Creek in Alaska, Lucky Friday in Idaho, no debt) with a third mine, Keno Hill in Yukon, Canada, held back until its licences are amended, and a pyrite circuit planned at Greens Creek.

Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.

Value rating · 17 Nov 2026 · start close 16 Nov 2026
CheapFairExpensive

Fair, on the expensive edge: 1.08× by the numbers, but the price needs only a peer-level multiple · low confidence

By the numbers alone this reads expensive: 1.079× against the 1.10× line. The desk calls a share expensive only with a written reason that the market's assumption will not hold, and here it has none: the price needs the two mines valued at about 15.4 times their margin, inside what the market pays like-for-like silver producers (Endeavour about 15.0 – 15.5×). So the label is fair. It becomes expensive above US$12.82 (€11.64), where even the high reading of the peer multiple (16.3 times) leaves the expected value under the line; by the central numbers alone the line is crossed above US$11.99, shown as information, never as the label.

Confidence: low. By the numbers the share is 1.9% under the 1.1× line, and small changes move it either way: silver 1.3% higher (US$47.47) or the company's own 2026 cost guidance instead of the latest quarter (1.15×) make it fair by the numbers; costs as high as the full-year guidance implies for Q4 2026 (US$20.8 an ounce, partly because that guidance assumes lower gold, zinc and lead prices) make it 0.89×. The yardstick rests on three silver-led producers, one of them Hecla itself; the other two are Mexican, have shorter reserves and unsettled figures (a strike at First Majestic's San Dimas mine, a guidance cut at Endeavour). Keno Hill's and the pyrite circuit's earnings are estimates: no study exists for either.

You pay todayUS$12.22 · €11.09 a share
Close of Mon 16 Nov 2026 on the New York Stock Exchange (HL): US$12.22, from stoculator.com's dated price history, equal to the desk's nightly price record (its 13 Nov close, US$13.10, matches too).

What one share should be worth in Nov 2030, by the analyst's estimate:

30% chance it works
US$13.76€12.49if it works · 1.13×
US$12.95€11.76if it fails · 1.06×

Works means Keno Hill's licence amendments are granted by 31 Dec 2029 (company: about mid-2029), the related infrastructure is built and its mill is back at or above its Q3 2026 rate (about 415 tons a day; 440 permitted) by 16 Nov 2030, and the Greens Creek pyrite circuit is approved, built and running by then (company: complete late 2028).

Fails means That end state is not reached by 16 Nov 2030. Greens Creek and Lucky Friday keep producing and are valued the same way; Keno Hill stays held down (an estimated 1.5 Moz of silver a year, losing money after its capital) and is valued as a stalled mine per ounce; the pyrite circuit adds nothing. Half of these misses are counted as late (the plan arrives about 1.5 years after the horizon), half as a lasting stall.

Per share, after the new shares each path needs, so each value compares directly with today's price. € at the ECB reference rate of 16 Nov 2026 (1.1014 US$ per €); the rating itself is worked out in US dollars, and future exchange rates will differ.

Expected value in Nov 2030
US$13.19€11.98
You pay today
US$12.22€11.09
1.08× today's price+1.9% a year over 4 years
30% × 1.126× + 70% × 1.060× = 1.079×
chance it works × value if it works + chance it fails × value if it fails

Expensive at 1.10× or less, cheap at 2.00× or more. Expensive also needs a written reason; cheap also needs a written reason, a dated catalyst and no tripped thesis breaker.

Price levels · everything else fixed
Cheap belownone
Last close (Mon 16 Nov)US$12.22 €11.09
Expensive aboveUS$12.82 €11.64

By the central numbers alone the expensive line is crossed above US$11.99 (€10.89). The label turns expensive only above US$12.82, where even the high reading of the peer multiple (16.31 times the margin) leaves the expected value under the line: below that the desk has no written reason that the market is wrong.

The new shares and options each path needs are re-priced at each level.

No cheap price. Price alone won't make this share cheap; it would take good news (see “What would change the rating”).

Why is there no cheap price?

A share counts as cheap here if, on average, it should be worth at least 2.00 times its price by Nov 2030. Worked out on paper, that would happen at US$6.38 a share. But at that price a share would still be worth US$12.36 if the project stalls, because that value is fixed at today's prices (what the market pays today for this company or for similar stalled projects) and does not fall with the share price. The sum would then say you make money even if everything goes wrong, which is not believable: if the share really fell that far, the value if it stalls would fall with it. So the page shows no cheap price instead of a misleading number.

Beside the rating · not counted in it

At the rankings' own target: 1.01×. The rankings page's own target for a growing mid-size producer, 10 to 12 times EBITDA (yearly earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation), on the same plan gives 0.78 to 1.00 times today's price if it works (mid-point 0.89, before four years of cash flow) and an expected value of 1.01× with the counted value if it fails: under the 1.1× line on that yardstick. Shown beside the rating, never counted.

At the top metal price on the rankings: If gold were US$7,000/oz and silver US$108/oz, the top regular prices on the rankings page (not a forecast): value if it works 3.77×, expected value 3.54× (3.36× without late outcomes), with the multiple held at 15.0 times; in practice the market pays fewer times a much wider margin, so this overstates. Shown beside the rating, never counted.

The value at metal futures prices about three years out is pending for all 14 (exchange data on hold).

Why

Fair, on the expensive edge. At US$12.22 (close of Mon 16 Nov 2026) the expected value of a share in four years is 1.08 times today's price (about 1.9% a year). By the numbers that is just under the 1.1× line below which a share counts as expensive, but the desk calls a share expensive only when it can show why the market's assumption will not hold, and here it cannot. The expected value weighs what a share is worth if the plan works and if it fails by their chances. Hecla's two profitable mines, Greens Creek (Alaska) and Lucky Friday (Idaho), earn about US$431M a year at today's silver after their all-in sustaining cost (AISC: the full cost of an ounce, including the spending that keeps the mines going). Valued at 15.0 times that margin, the middle of the three silver-led producers the desk measures, plus four years of free cash flow, a share is worth 1.13 times today's price if the plan works and 1.06 times if not. The plan: Keno Hill's (Yukon) licences amended by the end of 2029 and its mill back at its 2026 rate, and a new pyrite circuit running at Greens Creek, by November 2030. The analyst's chance that it works (a judgement): 30%. For the share to be fair by the numbers the mines need about 15.4 times their margin, about what the best-paid of the other silver-led producers gets, so the evidence does not show that the price is too high.

What would change the rating

Price alone won't make this cheap: below about US$6.38, where the arithmetic would read cheap, the value if the plan fails (US$12.36 a share) is far above the price, and the desk's rule then shows no cheap level (a rule made for projects that may stall; for a producer it is flagged for review). With everything else fixed the cheap line needs silver near US$77. Dates to watch: 2026 production and 2027 guidance (about 26 Jan 2027), Keno Hill's 2027 guidance (February 2027), the pyrite circuit decision (2027), the Keno Hill licence amendments (company: about mid-2029).

Expensive above about US$12.82 (€11.64) with nothing else changed: from there even the high reading of the peer multiple (16.3 times the margin) leaves the expected value under the 1.1× line. By the central numbers alone the line is crossed above about US$11.99. It would also turn expensive at today's price if 2027 guidance (January–February 2027) shows the two mines' AISC at about US$17 an ounce or more (1.00×; 0.95× if their silver is also below 12.5 Moz), and it gets worse if Keno Hill's licence date moves past the end of 2029 or if shares sold under the at-the-market programme (a permission filed on 10 Nov 2026 to sell up to 50 million new shares into the market) pay for something worth less than it cost.

Thesis breakers

Set in advance: any one of these would mean the plan has failed or the rating must be redone.

Dated events to watch

WhenWhat
10 – 11 Dec 2026Last day to convert the Series B preferred shares (10 Dec); their cash redemption, about US$7.64M (11 Dec; 8-K of 10 Nov 2026)
Q4 2026Lucky Friday surface cooling commissioning (company)
about 26 Jan 20272026 production and 2027 guidance (the prior year's pattern)
February 2027Keno Hill's 2027 guidance (company, 3 Nov 2026)
about 17 Feb 2027FY2026 results and annual report (10-K): the share count shows any at-the-market sales; year-end reserves
spring 2027Yukon mine-waste guidelines (from the rankings row, not re-read)
late 2027 / late 2028Pyrite circuit: intermittent production with temporary equipment, if approved (late 2027); circuit complete (late 2028; company, subject to permits and final approval)
about mid-2029Keno Hill licence amendments, then the related infrastructure (company)
Try your own assumptions · private test

Move a slider, and the value, the rating and the two price levels are worked out again with the same arithmetic as the rating above. The gold mark on each scale is the desk's setting; tap a chip to jump to a value.

CheapFairExpensive
Worth in Nov 2030
You pay today
Chance it works
If it works
If it fails
Today's price against the two price levels
Cheap below
Today
Expensive above
Main assumptions
More judgement calls ()

The sliders run the analyst's own rating function (translated line by line from Python and tested against it on random inputs), so at the desk's settings they give exactly the card's numbers, and the two price levels are worked out again at each setting. The label here follows the numbers; cheap also needs the cheap line without late builds, and the written tests. Metal prices and costs are held flat to the end of the horizon. For this company the analyst's label differs from the numbers' label: see the note on the card.

At other metal prices

The same function at the rankings page's regular price columns: sensitivities, not forecasts. The multiple (15.02 times the margin) is held; the two mines' margin, Keno Hill's cash flow, the pyrite circuit's margin, tax and four years of free cash flow are re-run at each price; the gold credit moves with gold on 53,000 ounces a year; costs, ounces, Keno Hill's stalled value and its cap are held; lead and zinc do not move. At much higher silver the market pays fewer times a wider margin, so the upper columns overstate. The ±10% rows move both metals from the 16 Nov closes. Sensitivities, not forecasts.

Swipe the table sideways for more columns →

PriceExpected valueIf it worksIf it failsCheap belowExpensive above
−10% (gold US$3,467.7 / silver US$42.17)0.87× · expensive0.90×0.86×noneUS$10.35
+10% (gold US$4,238.3 / silver US$51.54)1.29× · fair1.35×1.26×noneUS$15.29
gold US$3,500 / silver US$450.97× · expensive1.01×0.96×noneUS$11.54
gold US$4,500 / silver US$691.91× · fair2.02×1.86×noneUS$22.74
gold US$5,500 / silver US$852.57× · cheap2.73×2.50×already cheapUS$30.71
gold US$6,500 / silver US$1003.20× · cheap3.41×3.11×already cheapUS$38.26
gold US$7,000 / silver US$1083.54× · cheap3.77×3.44×already cheapUS$42.23

How we got this

Show the full calculationThe key steps first; every step and input one tap further

Hecla Mining is worth about US$13.76 a share in Nov 2030 if the plan works and US$12.95 if it fails. At a 30% chance the expected value is US$13.19, 1.08× today's US$12.22: fair.

The calculation in brief

Each step says first what its numbers are, then what the step does, then shows the sum.

Today

1What the market pays today
The numbers
671.777M
shares in issue (10-Q cover, 30 Oct 2026)
US$12.22
closing share price, Mon 16 Nov 2026
US$691.6M
cash, no borrowings (30 Sep 2026)
What this step does

Shares times price is what the whole company costs on the stock market today; less its cash, what the market pays for the mines (enterprise value). Everything below is compared with this price.

Calculation
671.777M × US$12.22 = US$8,209.1M; − US$691.6M cash = US$7,517.5M for the mines

If it works

2The two producing mines
The numbers
13.25 Moz
silver a year from Greens Creek and Lucky Friday (2026 guidance midpoints)
US$46.859 − US$14.34
silver price less the all-in sustaining cost an ounce (Q3 2026, after by-product credits)
15.02×
what the market pays silver-led producers per dollar of yearly margin (median of three)
What this step does

The mines are valued like comparable silver producers today: a multiple of the yearly margin they earn at today's silver. Both branches value them the same way.

Calculation
13.25 × (46.859 − 14.34) = US$430.9M a year; × 15.02 = US$6,471.8M
3Keno Hill restored and the pyrite circuit running
The numbers
US$16.2M
Keno Hill's yearly margin back at its Q3 2026 rate, after its sustaining capital (estimate)
US$59.8M
the pyrite circuit's yearly margin, 60% of its metal value (estimate; no study)
What this step does

If the plan works, both are producing by 16 Nov 2030 and are valued by the same multiple, on their own margins; nothing is added before they produce.

Calculation
15.02 × (US$430.9M + US$59.8M + US$16.2M) = US$7,613.8M for all three
4Four years of free cash flow
The numbers
US$276.6M
a year at today's metal: the mines' margin less exploration, growth capital, Keno Hill's held-down losses and tax, plus interest on cash
US$75M + US$60M
the circuit build and Keno Hill's new infrastructure (estimates), paid in the works case
What this step does

Cash the company earns before the horizon belongs to the shareholders in both branches.

Calculation
4 × US$276.6M = US$1,106.5M; works case + two years of circuit margin after tax − builds = US$1,066.9M
5Adding up: one share if it works
The numbers
US$9,364.7M
the three operations + cash (less the preferred shares redeemed in December) + four years of cash flow
680.64M
all the shares there will be: in issue, plus share awards that turn into shares, plus new award shares for four years at today's price
What this step does

No share sale is needed in either branch: the mines pay for the plan.

Calculation
(US$7,613.8M + US$683.9M + US$1,066.9M) ÷ 680.64M = US$13.76; ÷ US$12.22 = 1.126× today's price

If it fails

6If it stalls
The numbers
US$200.3M
Keno Hill as a stalled mine: US$206.34 per gold-equivalent ounce (silver projects with a feasibility study or permit) on 0.9706 Moz
no circuit
the pyrite circuit adds nothing
What this step does

The two mines keep producing and are valued as above; Keno Hill stays held down.

Calculation
(US$6,672.0M + US$683.9M + US$1,106.5M) ÷ 680.64M = US$12.43 a share = 1.017×
7If it comes late
The numbers
1.5 years
how late
10.7% a year
the desk's required return, used to discount the late value
US$73.8M
the extra cash Keno Hill burns while it waits
What this step does

A late plan: the stalled value plus the plan's extra value, discounted for the delay, less the cash Keno Hill burns meanwhile.

Calculation
stalled + (works − stalled) ÷ 1.10668^1.5 − the cash burnt = US$13.46 a share = 1.102×
8Value if it fails: late and stalled together
The numbers
50%
of the misses are late (an estimate nobody measures yet)
50%
are a lasting stall
What this step does

Each kind of miss counts by its share.

Calculation
0.50 × US$13.46 + 0.50 × US$12.43 = US$12.95 = 1.060× today's price

The result

9Weighing the two futures
The numbers
30%
the desk's chance that the plan works
1.126×
if it works
1.060×
if it fails
What this step does

Each future counts by its chance. Over 4.00 years, 1.10× or less is expensive and 2.00× or more is cheap; between is fair. Expensive and cheap also need the written tests.

Calculation
0.30 × 1.126 + 0.70 × 1.060 = 1.079× = US$13.19
10The two price levels
The numbers
1.10× and 2.00×
the expensive and cheap lines
re-priced
the new shares and the options at each price
What this step does

The share prices at which, everything else as above, the rating would turn.

Calculation
solved by the function at each price = expensive above US$12.82 · no cheap price (see the price levels at the top)
11The written test for expensive
The numbers
1.079×
the expected value, under the 1.10× line by the numbers
1.153×
the expected value at the high reading of the multiple, 16.31×
What this step does

Expensive also needs a written reason that the market's assumption will not hold. The price needs the mines at about 15.4 times their margin, inside what like-for-like silver producers are paid, so that reason is missing and the label is fair. It turns expensive where even the high multiple gives less than the line.

Calculation
high multiple at US$12.22: 1.153× ≥ 1.10×; under the line above US$12.82 = fair (expensive by the numbers alone)

Judgement calls to challenge

Where a reasonable person could choose differently, and what that would do. Each result is the model re-run with that one change; the sliders above let you combine them.

Chance the plan works
We used: Desk 30% → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Rankings row before the deep dive 40%1.09× · expensive
  • 20% (10 points lower)1.07× · expensive
  • 40% (10 points higher)1.09× · expensive
About this input
The analyst's estimate: Keno Hill's licences by end-2029 (about 0.47) × rebuilt and back at its rate by November 2030 (about 0.75) × the pyrite circuit running by then (about 0.80) ≈ 0.28, rounded to 30%. No measured base rates exist yet; the date has already slipped once. The chance barely moves the result.
Silver price, held flat
We used: Desk US$46.859 (COMEX, 16 Nov) · gold US$3,853 → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • US$45 · gold US$3,5000.97× · expensive
  • US$69 · gold US$4,5001.91× · fair
  • US$85 · gold US$5,5002.57× · cheap
  • US$100 · gold US$6,5003.20× · cheap
  • US$108 · gold US$7,0003.54× · cheap
About this input
The chips are the gold and silver rankings' price columns (they move gold too), not forecasts. At much higher silver the market pays fewer times a wider margin, so high settings overstate.
The two mines' value, × their yearly margin
We used: Desk 15.02× (silver-led median) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Two other silver producers 13.89×1.01× · expensive
  • Table as printed 14.85×1.07× · expensive
  • Endeavour, 16 Nov 15.47×1.11× · fair
  • High reading 16.31×1.15× · fair
  • Hecla's own today 17.45×1.21× · fair
  • First Majestic 12.76×0.95× · expensive
  • All producers 6.36×0.58× · expensive
About this input
What buyers pay for Greens Creek and Lucky Friday as a multiple of their yearly margin after all costs (AISC), at the silver price above. 15.02× is the median of the three silver-led producers once Hecla's own row is put on one basis (17.59×); fair by the numbers needs about 15.4×. 6.36× is the median of all producers, most of them gold-led.
All-in sustaining cost, US$ an ounce
We used: Desk US$14.34 (Q3 2026) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • 2026 guide midpoint US$12.001.15× · fair
  • Nine months US$9.371.22× · fair
  • Q4 implied by the guide US$20.820.89× · expensive
  • Breaker line US$17.001.00× · expensive
About this input
After by-product credits; covers the two mines and head office, not Keno Hill. The rule uses the latest quarter, as for the peers. The full-year guide assumes gold US$4,000, zinc US$1.40 and lead US$0.85, so its implied Q4 is not a 2027 signal. 2027 guidance above US$17 is a thesis breaker.
Misses that are a late build
We used: Desk 50% → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • None (the cheap test)1.05× · expensive
About this input
Of the outcomes that miss the works state, the share that is a build that comes late rather than a stall. Nobody measures this yet; the cheap test uses none. A late build can be worth less than a stall: it still needs the build money, raised by selling new shares, and it counts later, while a stalled project spends nothing more.
Keno Hill silver while held down, Moz a year
We used: Desk 1.5 Moz (estimate) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • 1.8 Moz1.08× · expensive
  • 1.2 Moz1.08× · expensive
  • 1.0 Moz (breaker line)1.07× · expensive
About this input
An estimate: Q4 2026 as implied by the 2026 guide, times four. 2027 guidance below 1.0 Moz is a thesis breaker.
Keno Hill if it stalls, US$ an ounce
We used: Desk US$206.34 (silver, feasibility / permitted) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Next group down US$60.681.07× · expensive
About this input
Per gold-equivalent ounce of Keno Hill's resource, capped at what Hecla's own price implies (US$1,077, not binding).
Pyrite circuit margin, share of its metal value
We used: Desk 60% (estimate) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • 40%1.06× · expensive
  • 80%1.10× · fair
About this input
No study exists for the circuit (scoping only): 1.0 – 1.2 Moz of silver and 10 – 15 koz of gold a year by the company; the margin is the desk's estimate.
Pyrite circuit build cost
We used: Desk US$75M (estimate) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • US$150M (breaker line)1.07× · expensive
About this input
The company has published no capital cost.
Interest on cash, US$M a year
We used: Desk US$30.3M (estimate) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Left out1.07× · expensive
About this input
Q3 2026 'other income', where interest sits, times four, before tax; cash held flat. Interest is not shown separately.
Listed shareholdings counted, US$M
We used: Desk: not added → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Added US$121.2M1.09× · expensive
About this input
Hecla holds US$121.2M of listed shares (30 Sep 2026). The peers' values carry their own holdings, so the desk leaves them out.
Shares sold under the at-the-market programme, M
We used: Desk: none → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • All 50M, half the money wasted1.04× · expensive
  • All 50M, all wasted1.01× · expensive
About this input
Permission filed on 10 Nov 2026 to sell up to 50 million new shares into the market; none reported sold, no use stated. Shares sold at the market price bring in their value; only money spent on something worth less than it cost lowers the value.
Tax rate
We used: Desk 20.3% (nine months 2026) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • 25%1.07× · expensive
About this input
The nine-month 2026 tax provision divided by pre-tax income.
Gold credit: the gold price it was earned at
We used: Desk: credit as reported (no re-pricing) → 1.08× · expensive by the numbers alone (the card's label: fair)
Alternatives, one at a time:
  • Q3's realised US$4,279 (re-priced to today)1.03× · expensive
About this input
The Q3 AISC used Hecla's realised gold of US$4,279. Re-pricing only Hecla's credit to today's gold (the peers not re-priced) gives 1.03×; the checker's estimate with the peers re-priced too stays fair. Not counted.

Every step

The analyst's arithmetic, line by lineAs written in the rating, with the metal-price table

Codes in the analyst's own notes: E = expected value as a multiple of today's price; Mw, Mf = value if it works, if it fails; pw = chance it works; q = share of misses that are late builds; hurdle = 1.5 times in four years (10.7% a year); A1 = valued at what the market pays similar companies today; C4 = new shares for the money still to raise; F1 = the value if it fails is capped at the company's own value today per unit; F2 = a rescue share sale at 80% of value; F3 = a late build valued like success, discounted for the delay; R1 = the written-reason test; X1 = currencies converted at the ECB rate of the start date; yardstick B = the rankings' own target, shown and never counted.

  • Start: US$12.22 (€11.09), close of Mon 16 Nov 2026, NYSE. Shares 671,777,326 net of treasury (10-Q cover, 30 Oct 2026): market value US$8,209.1M. Cash US$691.6M, no borrowings, finance leases US$11.2M left out (desk EV convention), listed equity investments US$121.2M left out (30 Sep 2026): EV US$7,517.5M.
  • Shares in both branches: 671.777M + 4.707M dilutive awards (Q3 2026 diluted less basic weighted count, 676.872M − 671.680M, less the 0.485M if-converted preferred shares, which are redeemed in cash) + 4.157M new award shares (US$12.7M a year for four years at the price) = 680.642M. No raise is needed in any branch.
  • The two mines (P1): Greens Creek 8.15 + Lucky Friday 5.10 = 13.25 Moz (2026 guidance midpoints) × (46.859 − 14.34, Q3 2026 AISC after by-product credits, which covers these two mines and corporate costs, not Keno Hill) = US$430.9M a year × 15.02 = US$6,471.8M. (Hecla's own EV is 17.45× that margin with Keno Hill at nil.)
  • Free cash flow a year at today's metal: 430.9 − exploration and pre-development 55.0 (outside the AISC) − Greens Creek growth capital 1.5 + Keno Hill held down (cash margin −19.2, capital −30.0, estimates) + interest 30.3 − tax 78.8 (20.3% of 430.9 + sustaining capital 147.5 − depreciation 146.2 − 55.0 − 19.2 + 30.3) = US$276.6M; four years US$1,106.5M.
  • Stalled (fail, no late part): 6,471.8 + Keno Hill stalled 0.9706 Moz gold-equivalent (all categories, 31 Dec 2025) × US$206.34 = 200.3 → EV 6,672.0 + cash 691.6 − preferred redemption 7.6 + cash flow 1,106.5 = US$8,462.5M ÷ 680.642M = US$12.43 = 1.0174×.
  • Works (producing by 16 Nov 2030, D-063): 15.02 × (430.9 + pyrite circuit 59.8 + restored Keno Hill 16.2, the last two estimates) = US$7,613.8M + cash 683.9 + cash flow 1,066.9 (1,106.5 + two years of circuit margin after tax 95.4 − circuit build 75 − Keno Hill infrastructure 60, estimates) = US$9,364.6M ÷ 680.642M = US$13.76 = 1.1259×.
  • Late (rule F3): stalled + the growth step discounted 1.5 years at 10.668% − the cash Keno Hill burns meanwhile = US$13.46 = 1.1017×; q = 0.5 → Mf = 1.0596× (US$12.95).
  • E = 0.30 × 1.1259 + 0.70 × 1.0596 = 1.0795 (+1.93% a year); E at q = 0 = 0.30 × 1.1259 + 0.70 × 1.0174 = 1.0500.
  • Levels (award shares re-priced at each price): central sum crosses 1.1× at US$11.9907; at the high multiple 16.31× at US$12.8168 (counted expensive level); cheap arithmetic (E and E at q = 0 both ≥ 2.0×) US$6.3797, against a stalled value of US$12.3640 a share there → no cheap level.
  • Low case (all-producer median 6.36×, Keno Hill stalled at the silver no-study median US$60.68/oz): Mw 0.598×, Mf 0.567×, E 0.577×. High case (16.31×, Keno Hill at US$218.58/oz): Mw 1.205×, Mf 1.132×, E 1.154×.
  • Metal ±10% (both metals): E 0.873× / 1.286×. At the 13 Nov close and metal (US$13.10; 3,886.3 / 49.121) E is 1.083×, also fair: not an effect of Monday's fall.
  • Yardstick B (stored, not counted; D-054): works-case EBITDA US$576.3M at US$3,500 / US$45 and US$629.4M at spot (two mines' margin + sustaining capital − exploration + Keno Hill back at its Q3 rate + the circuit; estimates for the last two); 10× the first and 12× the second, + net cash US$683.9M, ÷ 676.485M shares = 0.780× to 0.996× (mid-point 0.888×); with the counted fail value E = 0.3 × 0.888 + 0.7 × 1.0596 = 1.008×.
The rating function itself (Python)The exact code behind the card, the sliders and this calculation
# Hecla Mining (NYSE: HL) - value rating of 17 Nov 2026 (brief v0.5, D-063, D-064). US$M unless marked; share values US$.
# Start close Mon 16 Nov 2026. Rule set: P1 - the two producing mines (Greens Creek + Lucky Friday, with corporate costs)
# at the silver-led producer median of table C-3(a) x their AISC margin at today's metal (guided ounces x (silver -
# latest AISC, company basis, which excludes Keno Hill)). Counted multiple 15.02x: the whole silver-led group (fewer than
# five names, brief v0.5), with Hecla's own row corrected to one basis (17.59x: its 14.85x had multiplied Keno Hill's
# ounces by an AISC that excludes Keno Hill); the median is then Endeavour's. D-063 - 'works' is a producing state: a
# restored Keno Hill and the Greens Creek pyrite circuit are valued by the same producer rule on their own margins
# (estimates: no study exists), never before they produce. F1 - in the fail branch Keno Hill is a stalled asset at the
# silver 'FS / permitted, unfunded' median per oz AuEq, capped at Hecla's own value per oz at the start close.
# F3 - q = 0.5, a late plan = the stalled value plus the growth step discounted at the hurdle rate (10.668%/yr) for the
# delay, less the extra cash Keno Hill burns while waiting. Four years of free cash flow at today's metal, with interest
# on cash, are added in both branches. R1 - the label is expensive only where even the high reading of the peer multiple
# (mult_high) gives E under the line; levels() returns that price and, beside it, the price where the central sum
# crosses. Educational research, not personal financial advice.
DEFAULTS = dict(
    P=12.22,           # share price, US$ (start close Mon 16 Nov 2026, NYSE: HL)
    pw=0.30,           # chance the plan works (analyst's deep dive; the rankings row had 0.40)
    ag=46.859, au=3853.0,  # COMEX closes 16 Nov 2026, US$/oz
    mult=15.02,        # EV / AISC margin: silver-led median of C-3(a) v2 with Hecla's row corrected (Endeavour 15.02x)
    mult_high=16.31,   # high reading: median + half the gap to the group's highest (Hecla corrected, 17.59x); R1 level
    q=0.5,             # share of the not-works outcomes that are late or partial (rule F3, whole tenths, at most 0.5)
    delay=1.5,         # years a late plan runs behind the horizon; discounted at 10.668%/yr
    base_oz=13.25,     # Moz Ag a year, Greens Creek 8.15 + Lucky Friday 5.10 (2026 guidance midpoints, 3 Nov 2026)
    aisc=14.34,        # US$/oz Ag, Q3 2026 consolidated AISC after by-product credits (excludes Keno Hill)
    gold_koz=53.0,     # koz Au a year, Greens Creek (2026 guidance midpoint); payable rate assumed 1.0 (estimate)
    credit_gold_ref=3853.0,  # US$/oz gold at which the by-product credit equals the reported one (4279 = re-priced to Q3)
    sust=147.5,        # US$M a year sustaining capital inside the AISC (2026 guidance 142-153, midpoint)
    dda=146.2,         # US$M a year depreciation, Q3 2026 x 4 (for the tax line only)
    expl=55.0,         # US$M a year exploration and pre-development (2026 guidance), outside the AISC
    gc_growth=1.5,     # US$M a year Greens Creek growth capital (2026 guidance 1-2)
    tax=0.203,         # income and mining tax rate, nine months 2026 provision / pre-tax income
    interest=30.3,     # US$M a year before tax: Q3 2026 'other income' 7.575 x 4, where interest sits (estimate; cash held flat)
    kh_oz_full=3.852,  # Moz Ag a year, Keno Hill at its Q3 2026 rate (963,048 oz x 4; 415 tons a day of 440 permitted)
    kh_oz_low=1.5,     # Moz Ag a year while throughput is held down (estimate: Q4 2026 implied by the 2026 guide, 0.22-0.52 Moz, x 4)
    kh_rev=0.8189,     # Keno Hill metal sales per oz produced / realised silver, Q3 2026 (50.172 / 0.963048 / 63.62)
    kh_cost_full=101.6,  # US$M a year, Keno Hill costs applicable to sales at the Q3 2026 rate (25.402 x 4)
    kh_fixed=0.6,      # share of those costs that does not fall with throughput (estimate)
    kh_capex_low=30.0, # US$M a year Keno Hill capital while held down (estimate; 2026 guidance 55-59, all 'growth')
    kh_sust=30.0,      # US$M a year sustaining capital of a restored Keno Hill (estimate; not disclosed)
    kh_infra=60.0,     # US$M, infrastructure after the licence amendments (estimate; not disclosed)
    kh_stalled_per_oz=206.34,  # US$/oz AuEq, silver 'FS / permitted, unfunded' median (C-3(a) v2), capped (rule F1)
    pyr_ag=1.1, pyr_au=12.5,   # Moz Ag and koz Au a year from the pyrite circuit (company: 1.0-1.2 Moz, 10-15 koz)
    pyr_net=0.6,       # share of that metal's value left as margin after payable terms and costs (estimate)
    pyr_capex=75.0,    # US$M, pyrite circuit build (estimate; the company has published none)
    pyr_years=2.0,     # years of circuit output inside the horizon (complete late 2028, company)
    sbc=12.7,          # US$M a year of share awards, issued as new shares at the price P (nine months 2026 x 4/3)
    invest=0.0,        # US$M of listed equity investments counted (121.155 held; 0 = left inside the peer EV basis)
    atm_shares=0.0,    # M new shares sold under the at-the-market programme (up to 50), at P less 1.5%
    atm_waste=0.0,     # share of that money spent on something worth nothing
    years=4.0,         # horizon in years (lines 2.0^(y/4), 1.1^(y/4))
)
SHARES = 671.777326                 # M, net of treasury, 10-Q cover, 30 Oct 2026
AWARDS = 676.872 - 671.680 - 0.4847 # M dilutive awards: Q3 2026 diluted less basic weighted count (10-Q), less the
                                    # 0.4847M if-converted preferred shares (150,736 x 3.2154), redeemed in cash instead
CASH = 691.569                      # cash and equivalents, 30 Sep 2026 (no borrowings; finance leases 11.211 left out)
PREF = 150736 * 50.6806 / 1e6       # Series B preferred redeemed 11 Dec 2026 (8-K 10 Nov 2026)
AG0, AU0 = 46.859, 3853.0           # start-close metal, for the F1 cap
EV_TODAY = 12.22 * SHARES - CASH    # 7,517.5 at the start close
KH_AUEQ = (53.407 + 14.039 + 11.044) * AG0 / AU0 + 0.016   # Moz AuEq, Keno Hill all categories, 31 Dec 2025
R = 1.5 ** 0.25                     # hurdle, 10.668% a year

def base_margin(i, ag, au):
    return i['base_oz'] * (ag - i['aisc']) + i['gold_koz'] / 1000 * (au - i['credit_gold_ref'])

def kh_low(i, ag):
    """Keno Hill cash margin a year before capital, throughput held down (estimate)."""
    cost = i['kh_cost_full'] * (i['kh_fixed'] + (1 - i['kh_fixed']) * i['kh_oz_low'] / i['kh_oz_full'])
    return i['kh_oz_low'] * i['kh_rev'] * ag - cost

def kh_full(i, ag):
    """Keno Hill cash margin a year before capital at its Q3 2026 rate."""
    return i['kh_oz_full'] * i['kh_rev'] * ag - i['kh_cost_full']

def pyr_margin(i, ag, au):
    return i['pyr_net'] * (i['pyr_ag'] * ag + i['pyr_au'] / 1000 * au)

def _branches(i, P):
    ag, au, y, t = i['ag'], i['au'], i['years'], i['tax']
    base = base_margin(i, ag, au); khl = kh_low(i, ag); pyr = pyr_margin(i, ag, au)
    khw = max(0.0, kh_full(i, ag) - i['kh_sust'])                      # restored Keno Hill, AISC-style margin
    taxes = t * max(0.0, base + i['sust'] - i['dda'] - i['expl'] + khl + i['interest'])
    fcf_y = base - i['expl'] - i['gc_growth'] + khl - i['kh_capex_low'] + i['interest'] - taxes
    fcf_fail = y * fcf_y
    fcf_works = fcf_fail + i['pyr_years'] * pyr * (1 - t) - i['pyr_capex'] - i['kh_infra']
    cap = max(0.0, (EV_TODAY - i['mult'] * base_margin(i, AG0, AU0)) / KH_AUEQ)   # F1 cap, set at the start close
    kh_stalled = min(i['kh_stalled_per_oz'], cap) * KH_AUEQ
    ev_stalled = i['mult'] * base + kh_stalled
    ev_works = i['mult'] * (base + pyr + khw)
    atm_cash = i['atm_shares'] * P * 0.985 * (1 - i['atm_waste'])
    other = CASH - PREF + i['invest'] + atm_cash
    n = SHARES + AWARDS + y * i['sbc'] / P + i['atm_shares']
    Ms_ps = (ev_stalled + other + fcf_fail) / n
    Mw_ps = (ev_works + other + fcf_works) / n
    Mw_ps = max(Mw_ps, Ms_ps)                                          # works >= fail (brief v0.5)
    wait = i['delay'] * max(0.0, i['kh_capex_low'] - khl) / n          # cash Keno Hill burns during the delay
    Ml_ps = max(Ms_ps, Ms_ps + (Mw_ps - Ms_ps) / R ** i['delay'] - wait)
    Mf_ps = i['q'] * Ml_ps + (1 - i['q']) * Ms_ps
    return dict(base_margin=base, pyr_margin=pyr, kh_works_margin=khw, kh_low_cash=khl - i['kh_capex_low'],
                taxes=taxes, fcf_year=fcf_y, fcf4_fail=fcf_fail, fcf4_works=fcf_works, cap_per_oz=cap,
                kh_stalled=kh_stalled, ev_stalled=ev_stalled, ev_works=ev_works, shares=n,
                Mw_ps=Mw_ps, M_late_ps=Ml_ps, M_stalled_ps=Ms_ps, Mf_ps=Mf_ps)

def value(inp=None):
    i = dict(DEFAULTS, **(inp or {})); P = i['P']; b = _branches(i, P)
    E = (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['Mf_ps']) / P
    Eq0 = (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['M_stalled_ps']) / P
    return dict(b, Mw=b['Mw_ps'] / P, Mf=b['Mf_ps'] / P, M_late=b['M_late_ps'] / P, M_stalled=b['M_stalled_ps'] / P,
                E=E, E_q0=Eq0, per_year=E ** (1 / i['years']) - 1)

def _E(i, P):
    b = _branches(i, P)
    E = (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['Mf_ps']) / P
    Eq0 = (i['pw'] * b['Mw_ps'] + (1 - i['pw']) * b['M_stalled_ps']) / P
    return E, Eq0, b

def _cross(i, line, hi, both=False, lo=0.05, steps=4000):
    import math
    f = (lambda P: min(_E(i, P)[:2])) if both else (lambda P: _E(i, P)[0])
    prev = hi
    for k in range(steps + 1):
        P = hi * math.exp(math.log(lo / hi) * k / steps)
        if f(P) >= line:
            a, b = P, prev
            for _ in range(60):
                mid = (a + b) / 2
                a, b = (mid, b) if f(mid) >= line else (a, mid)
            return a
        prev = P
    return None

def levels(inp=None):
    i = dict(DEFAULTS, **(inp or {})); y = i['years']; hi = 10 * i['P']
    exp_sum = _cross(i, 1.1 ** (y / 4), hi)                              # central sum crosses the expensive line
    exp = _cross(dict(i, mult=i['mult_high']), 1.1 ** (y / 4), hi)       # R1: under the line even at the high multiple
    cheap = _cross(i, 2.0 ** (y / 4), hi, both=True)                     # both E and E at q = 0 must reach the cheap line
    fps = _E(i, cheap)[2]['M_stalled_ps'] if cheap else None
    return dict(expensive_above=exp, expensive_above_sum=exp_sum,
                cheap_below=(cheap if cheap and cheap > fps else None), cheap_arith=cheap, fail_ps_at_cheap=fps)

def label(inp=None):
    """Fair unless the price is above the R1 level (expensive) or a cheap level exists and the price is below it."""
    i = dict(DEFAULTS, **(inp or {})); l = levels(i)
    if l['expensive_above'] is not None and i['P'] > l['expensive_above']: return 'expensive'
    if l['cheap_below'] is not None and i['P'] < l['cheap_below']: return 'cheap'
    return 'fair'

if __name__ == '__main__':
    r = value(); l = levels()
    print({k: round(v, 4) for k, v in r.items()}); print(l); print(label())

# Low / high case: mult 6.36 (all-producer median, written P1 low) with Keno Hill stalled at US$60.68/oz -> E 0.577;
# mult 16.31 with Keno Hill stalled at US$218.58/oz -> E 1.154.
# Test line (run in the folder holding this file):
# python3 -c "import hecla as m; r = m.value(); l = m.levels(); assert (round(r['E'], 3), round(r['E_q0'], 3), round(r['Mw'], 3), round(r['Mf'], 3)) == (1.079, 1.05, 1.126, 1.06); assert round(l['expensive_above'], 2) == 12.82 and round(l['expensive_above_sum'], 2) == 11.99 and l['cheap_below'] is None and round(l['cheap_arith'], 2) == 6.38 and m.label() == 'fair'; print('ok')"
The inputs (37)Each marked fact, estimate or desk choice, with its source

Fact from a filing, exchange or agency · Estimate the desk's own · Desk choice a judgement you can challenge.

The function's inputs

Share price at the start closeFact
12.22
share price, US$ (start close Mon 16 Nov 2026, NYSE: HL)
Chance the plan worksDesk choice
0.3
chance the plan works (analyst's deep dive; the rankings row had 0.40)
Silver price, held flatFact
46.859
COMEX closes 16 Nov 2026, US$/oz
Gold price, held flatFact
3,853
COMEX closes 16 Nov 2026, US$/oz
The two mines' value, × their yearly marginDesk choice
15.02
EV / AISC margin: silver-led median of C-3(a) v2 with Hecla's row corrected (Endeavour 15.02x)
High reading of the multiple (the expensive level)Desk choice
16.31
high reading: median + half the gap to the group's highest (Hecla corrected, 17.59x); R1 level
Misses that are a late buildDesk choice
0.5
share of the not-works outcomes that are late or partial (rule F3, whole tenths, at most 0.5)
How late a late build is, yearsDesk choice
1.5
years a late plan runs behind the horizon; discounted at 10.668%/yr
base ozDesk choice
13.25
Moz Ag a year, Greens Creek 8.15 + Lucky Friday 5.10 (2026 guidance midpoints, 3 Nov 2026)
All-in sustaining cost, US$ an ounceDesk choice
14.34
US$/oz Ag, Q3 2026 consolidated AISC after by-product credits (excludes Keno Hill)
gold kozEstimate
53
koz Au a year, Greens Creek (2026 guidance midpoint); payable rate assumed 1.0 (estimate)
Gold credit: the gold price it was earned atDesk choice
3,853
US$/oz gold at which the by-product credit equals the reported one (4279 = re-priced to Q3)
sustDesk choice
147.5
US$M a year sustaining capital inside the AISC (2026 guidance 142-153, midpoint)
ddaDesk choice
146.2
US$M a year depreciation, Q3 2026 x 4 (for the tax line only)
explDesk choice
55
US$M a year exploration and pre-development (2026 guidance), outside the AISC
gc growthDesk choice
1.5
US$M a year Greens Creek growth capital (2026 guidance 1-2)
Tax rateDesk choice
0.203
income and mining tax rate, nine months 2026 provision / pre-tax income
Interest on cash, US$M a yearEstimate
30.3
US$M a year before tax: Q3 2026 'other income' 7.575 x 4, where interest sits (estimate; cash held flat)
kh oz fullDesk choice
3.852
Moz Ag a year, Keno Hill at its Q3 2026 rate (963,048 oz x 4; 415 tons a day of 440 permitted)
Keno Hill silver while held down, Moz a yearEstimate
1.5
Moz Ag a year while throughput is held down (estimate: Q4 2026 implied by the 2026 guide, 0.22-0.52 Moz, x 4)
kh revDesk choice
0.8189
Keno Hill metal sales per oz produced / realised silver, Q3 2026 (50.172 / 0.963048 / 63.62)
kh cost fullDesk choice
101.6
US$M a year, Keno Hill costs applicable to sales at the Q3 2026 rate (25.402 x 4)
kh fixedEstimate
0.6
share of those costs that does not fall with throughput (estimate)
kh capex lowEstimate
30
US$M a year Keno Hill capital while held down (estimate; 2026 guidance 55-59, all 'growth')
kh sustEstimate
30
US$M a year sustaining capital of a restored Keno Hill (estimate; not disclosed)
kh infraEstimate
60
US$M, infrastructure after the licence amendments (estimate; not disclosed)
Keno Hill if it stalls, US$ an ounceDesk choice
206.34
US$/oz AuEq, silver 'FS / permitted, unfunded' median (C-3(a) v2), capped (rule F1)
pyr agDesk choice
1.1
Moz Ag and koz Au a year from the pyrite circuit (company: 1.0-1.2 Moz, 10-15 koz)
pyr auDesk choice
12.5
Moz Ag and koz Au a year from the pyrite circuit (company: 1.0-1.2 Moz, 10-15 koz)
Pyrite circuit margin, share of its metal valueEstimate
0.6
share of that metal's value left as margin after payable terms and costs (estimate)
Pyrite circuit build costEstimate
75
US$M, pyrite circuit build (estimate; the company has published none)
pyr yearsDesk choice
2
years of circuit output inside the horizon (complete late 2028, company)
sbcDesk choice
12.7
US$M a year of share awards, issued as new shares at the price P (nine months 2026 x 4/3)
Listed shareholdings counted, US$MDesk choice
0
US$M of listed equity investments counted (121.155 held; 0 = left inside the peer EV basis)
Shares sold under the at-the-market programme, MDesk choice
0
M new shares sold under the at-the-market programme (up to 50), at P less 1.5%
Share of that money wastedDesk choice
0
share of that money spent on something worth nothing
Years to the end of the horizonDesk choice
4
horizon in years (lines 2.0^(y/4), 1.1^(y/4))

Every number here is computed by the same model that drives the rating card and the sliders, so the three cannot disagree.

Sources

How we rate a share, with two worked examples →

Back to all value ratings (14 companies)

Human judgement (Chung Huynh) on what matters. Machine effort on everything else.

Chung Huynh is an independent equity researcher, not a licensed financial adviser.

The author may own shares in companies rated here and may buy or sell them at any time.

A rating is reviewed when the price crosses one of its two levels, after major news or a dated catalyst, and at least every three months.

Ratings use today's metal prices. Every number shows its date and source; figures marked estimate are the desk's own.

Educational research, not personal financial advice.